[518] in Commercialization & Privatization of the Internet

home help back first fref pref prev next nref lref last post

Re: addressing needs

daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Richard Mandelbaum)
Fri Apr 5 03:47:16 1991

To: brian@napa.telebit.com
Cc: roy@alanine.phri.nyu.edu, com-priv@psi.com
In-Reply-To: Your message of Thu, 04 Apr 91 08:59:30 -0800.
Date: Thu, 04 Apr 91 13:08:14 -0500
From: Richard Mandelbaum <rma@tsar.cc.rochester.edu>

I think those who comment on computers etc being pie-in the sky for the
urban community in the inner city should actually go out and speak
to those inner city kids and parents whom they are defending from the danger
of being exposed to such things as LANS and routers.
Some kids and some parents really do want their kids to take part in the 21st century. They want their kids exposed to such technology and get to use it.
They suspect that such knowledge might help their kids out in the future.
i think it is very patronizing to explain how the inner city kids don't 
need such toys. Perhaps they don't consider tham toys but a vital component
of 21st century life. 
Trying to solve all the problems of the ghetto via networking is of course
absurd. Trying to help some kids and expose them to a an ever more popular
tool is perhaps not so absurd. At least the potential users think it is not so 
absurd despite the "knowledge" of the self appointed network experts.

____________________

	    > Yes, the [K-12 community] will need computers, LANs, and routers 
	but they
	    > will be provided legislation.  What a concept!  :-)

	 	   Perhaps I am being closed-minded and urbano-centric (and per
	haps this
	    is a socio-political debate that doesn't really belong on this list
	).  At any
	    rate, from my vantage point of living in New York City, providing c
	omputers,
	    LANs, and routers to the K-12 community seems like an absurd pie-in
	-the-sky
	    goal and the people who are pushing it have absolutely no grasp of 
	reality.

	    . . .  I'm sorry, folks, but when you look at what needs
	    improving in inner-city K-12 school systems, I just don't see compu
	ters,
	    LANs, and routers even making the list.

	 My original comment was made tongue-in-cheek.  You do have a point
	 though.  Social change is what is required.  I really think that
	 legislation will do little to help the students at the K-12 grade
	 levels.  And that comment stands regardless of whether we speak of
	 LANs or reading primers.

	 Brian Lloyd, WB6RQN                              Telebit Corporation
	 Network Systems Architect                        1315 Chesapeake Terra
	ce 
	 brian@napa.telebit.com                           Sunnyvale, CA 94089-1
	100
	 voice (408) 745-3103                             FAX (408) 734-3333

home help back first fref pref prev next nref lref last post