[10635] in Commercialization & Privatization of the Internet

home help back first fref pref prev next nref lref last post

Re: Open Platform 2.0

daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (aselene@aol.com)
Wed Mar 2 21:35:47 1994

From: aselene@aol.com
To: com-priv@psi.com
Date: Wed, 02 Mar 94 16:14:47 EST

Mr. McCandlish,

Thank you for forwarding EFFs Open Platform public policy statement.  After
reading it I withdraw my apology for lampooning Mitch Kapor and your
organization in my prior correspondence.

Contrary to your claims of Jeffersonian heritage, your platform reveals the
true nature of your efforts to appropriate and control the property of others
to advance what you cavalierly call the civic good.  I am refering in
particular to your call for "a new social contract" ensuring a "Universal
Service" guarantee.  

You observe that "Re-creation of old patterns of subsidy may no longer be
possible nor necessarily desirable, but serious thought must be given to
sources of funds that will guarantee that users who are economically
disadvantaged will still have access to basic communications services." You
then quite eloquently define this brand new middle class entitlement.

Further reading reveals the principle by which these funds will be obtained :

"The scope of these obligations should certainly be proportionate to the
companies' market presence."

I believe that this fundamental principle was first described in general
terms over one hundred years ago - "From each according to his ability - to
each according to his need."  

Wearing the cloak of Thomas Jefferson while practicing the philosophy of Karl
Marx is both deceitful and downright shameful.  Truth in labeling demands
that you make it very clear, particularly to people from whom you solicit
funds, exactly what you stand for.

I would very much like to maintain our dialogue in hopes that you may someday
correct this fundamental error.  Meanwhile, carry on with your other very
appropriate efforts to reduce government intrusion in our lives.

Respectfully,

Adam Selene


home help back first fref pref prev next nref lref last post