[41780] in bugtraq
XSS vulnerabilities in Google.com
daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Watchfire Research)
Wed Dec 21 19:26:51 2005
Content-class: urn:content-classes:message
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain;
charset="us-ascii"
Date: Wed, 21 Dec 2005 15:05:50 +0200
Message-ID: <0FF3BDA8C55900469FA6011BEFC06F4340CE57@2WFILEMAIL.israel.ottawa.watchfire.com>
From: "Watchfire Research" <security-research@watchfire.com>
To: <bugtraq@securityfocus.com>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
//=====================>> Security Advisory <<=====================//
---------------------------------------------------------------------
XSS vulnerabilities in Google.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------
--[ Author: Yair Amit , Watchfire Corporation http://www.watchfire.com
--[ Discovery Date: 15/11/2005
--[ Initial Vendor Response: 15/11/2005
--[ Issue solved: 01/12/2005
--[ Website: www.google.com
--[ Severity: High
--[ Summary
Two XSS vulnerabilities were identified in the Google.com website,
which allow an attacker to impersonate legitimate members of Google's
services or to mount a phishing attack.
Although Google uses common XSS countermeasures, a successful attack
is possible, when using UTF-7 encoded payloads.
--[ Background
Google's URL redirection script
---------------------------------------------------------------------
The script (http://www.google.com/url?q=...) is normally used for
redirecting the browser from Google's website to other sites.
For example, the following request will redirect the browser
to http://www.watchfire.com :
- http://www.google.com/url?q=http://www.watchfire.com
When the parameter (q) is passed to the script with illegal format
(The format seems to be: http://domain), a "403 Forbidden" page
returns to the user, informing that the query was illegal.
The parameter's value appears in the html returned to the user.
If http://www.google.com/url?q=USER_INPUT is requested, the text in
the "403 Forbidden" response would be:
- "Your client does not have permission to get URL
/url?q=USER_INPUT from this server."
The server response lacks charset encoding enforcement, such as:
* Response headers: "Content-Type: text/html; charset=[encoding]".
* Response body: "<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" (...)
charset=[encoding]/>".
Google's 404 NOT FOUND mechanism
---------------------------------------------------------------------
When requesting a page which doesn't exist under www.google.com, a
404 NOT FOUND response is returned to the user, with the original
path requested.
If http://www.google.com/NOTFOUND is requested, the following text
appears in the response:
"Not Found
The requested URL /NOTFOUND was not found on this server."
The server response lacks charset encoding enforcement, such as:
* Response headers: "Content-Type: text/html; charset=[encoding]".
* Response body: "<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" (...)
charset=[encoding]/>".
--[ XSS vulnerabilities
While the aforementioned mechanisms (URL redirection script,
404 NOT FOUND) escape common characters used for XSS, such as <>
(triangular parenthesis) and apostrophes, it fails to handle
hazardous UTF-7 encoded payloads.
Therefore, when sending an XSS attack payload, encoded in UTF-7, the
payload will return in the response without being altered.
For the attack to succeed (script execution), the victim's browser
should treat the XSS payload as UTF-7.
--[ IE charset encoding Auto-Selection
If 'Encoding' is set to 'Auto-Select', and Internet-Explorer finds a
UTF-7 string in the first 4096 characters of the response's body,
it will set the charset encoding to UTF-7 automatically, unless a
certain charset encoding is already enforced.
This automatic encoding selection feature makes it possible to mount
UTF-7 XSS attacks on Google.com.
--[ Solution
Google solved the aforementioned issues at 01/12/2005, by using
character encoding enforcement.
--[ Acknowledgement
The author would like to commend the Google Security Team for their
cooperation and communication regarding this vulnerability.
