[31160] in North American Network Operators' Group
RE: Confussion over multi-homing
daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Roeland M.J. Meyer)
Thu Sep 14 15:16:27 2000
Message-ID: <1148622BC878D411971F0060082B042C36C2@hawk.lvrmr.mhsc.com>
From: "Roeland M.J. Meyer" <rmeyer@MHSC.com>
To: David Lott <dlott@msncomm.com>, nanog@merit.edu
Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2000 12:15:41 -0700
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain
Errors-To: owner-nanog-outgoing@merit.edu
David Lott: Thursday, September 14, 2000 10:34 AM wrote:
> First, allow me to state the assumptions that I'm under. I understand
> the policy to state that if a business needs to multi-home
> and requires
> less space than a /20, then they should request this space from their
> ISP. I also understand that there are filters at the /20
> boundaries in
> order to minimize the size of the routing table.
>
> Question: Doesn't this break multi-homing for end users that
> need less
> than a /20?
Yep, this has been a topic here before...no real resolution. You didn't
really need to prove the case, it has already been proven.
The only way that you can do it is to justify a /20 or larger, get
portable IP space from ARIN, and make your own peering arrangements with
your upstreams. Considering that you will probably burn the best part of
the /20 with distributed services, this increases your internal
administration costs substantially. What you will have is a very
low-density use net-block, but at least you can now multi-home and even
have some geographical independence, for multiple-site use. If you have
good admins, the whole thing can be folded/collapsed into about 20
physical servers, or less (Lintel boxen keep the costs low too, see:
VA-Linux, about two racks).
Is this wasteful of IP space? ...absolut!
Is this necessary? ...sometimes.
If you are building a H-Rel/Hi-Avail/Hi-Secure site(s), you ain't
getting there without multi-homing with at least three providers. If you
have multiple sites, you can't get there without multi-homing on an ASN
that will be advertised (at least a /20, probably a /19).
Do I tell clients this? ... absolut!
Have I done this for clients? ... Yep, and I ain't saying who for
either.
---
R O E L A N D M . J . M E Y E R
CEO, Morgan Hill Software Company, Inc.
Managing Architect
Tel: (925)373-3954
Fax: (925)373-9781
http://staff.mhsc.com/rmeyer
