[12482] in North American Network Operators' Group
Re: Traffic Engineering
daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Pushpendra Mohta)
Wed Sep 17 19:36:54 1997
From: Pushpendra Mohta <pushp@CERF.NET>
In-Reply-To: <3.0.2.32.19970917101904.006b00a4@zeus.geo.net> from "Kent W. England" at "Sep 17, 97 10:19:04 am"
To: kwe@geo.net (Kent W. England)
Date: Wed, 17 Sep 1997 16:23:21 -0700 (PDT)
Cc: pkavi@pcmail.casc.com, dorian@blackrose.org, pkline@cisco.com,
nanog@merit.edu
Kent W. England writes:
>
> Here are some examples:
>
> > 2. Identify which % of traffic, if any, has regional locality.
> > For pure Internet traffic, the probability that the source and
> > destinatino of traffic are within the same metropolitan area
> > tends to be low (10% or lower for metros within the US).
>
> This is true only so long as the density of the Internet is low. This is so
> because so long as the density is low, few of your neighbors will be on the
> Internet and therefore local issues are irrelevant. However, at some point,
> the density of the Internet gets to a critical point, say 30% to 40%. At
> that point a pizza parlor owner says to himself "two out of every five of
> my customers are on the Internet. Perhaps I need a web page." And,
> suddenly, pizza on the Net makes a lot of sense and the traffic patterns
> shift. As the density grows to 90%, local traffic becomes dominant over
> distant traffic.
Even in the scenario where physical proximity automatically implied
network proximity, I think the assumption that local traffic will
dominate communications needs to be revisited. It is true today, only
because that is how people live lives and conduct business _today_. The
concept of "community" today is geographical.. the communities of
tommorrow may not be so restricted.
>
> Another example is distributed web hosting. When distributed web hosting
> takes off, your backbone will be heavily discounted and your peripheral
> interconnect bandwidth will be woefully short. Web traffic will zoom as
> performance dramatically improves, but your backbone bandwidth will drop.
> That breaks your traffic model.
>
This is true of a business model based around content distrubution only.
Most ISPs of size will have both publishers and consumers of information
so the backbones utilization should be balanced.
> So, by all means, do your traffic studies, but be prepared to throw them
> out or re-write them when the environment changes. Then throw bandwidth
> where it will do the most good. :-)
>
No debate here.
> --Kent
>
>
--pushpendra
Pushpendra Mohta pushp@cerf.net +1 619 812 3908
TCG CERFnet http://www.cerf.net +1 619 812 3995 (FAX)
