[107838] in North American Network Operators' Group
Today's Point-2Point WAN Options
daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Chris Kleban)
Mon Sep 15 19:33:39 2008
From: Chris Kleban <Chris.Kleban@citrix.com>
To: "nanog@nanog.org" <nanog@nanog.org>
Date: Mon, 15 Sep 2008 16:33:26 -0700
Errors-To: nanog-bounces@nanog.org
Hello Nanog,
I'm currently looking into what are the options for enabling inter-datacent=
er communication.
Our current solution is to use ipsec/gre tunnels traversing over the Intern=
et. The specific needs the new solution must meet are:
- The ability to run end-to-end QOS.
- Dedicated bandwidth
- Support 1gbps transfer rates
- Enable communication between 3 locations
The options I have looked into so far are:
- Layer 2 Ethernet (Virtual Private Line): This service seems to be offered=
by a lot of ISPs using various networking techniques. The price point is a=
ttractive however packets are forwarded only at best effort across the ISP'=
s network which means the quality of the service will directly reflect the =
ISP's network performance.
- Traditional Leased Line (dsX/ocX): This service seems to be more expensiv=
e then wavelength services however meets my needs.
- WaveLength Services (oc3-10gig): This service seems to be cheaper then tr=
aditional leased lines when comparing similar bandwidth. However, availabil=
ity is limited to on-net buildings. This solution meets my needs.
- MPLS based VPN solutions: Seems to be a good point to multipoint technolo=
gy with QOS offerings. However, the price seems to be around the same as wa=
velength services for the amount of bandwidth we require. If the number of =
data centers we were looking to connect was larger then this option would b=
e more attractive. This solution meets my needs.
Based on my needs and what my options are I am leaning towards point to poi=
nt wavelength services connecting my 3 locations in a loop like fashion.
Are there any other options I should consider?
Are my descriptions of the today's possible solutions inaccurate?
Are there any thoughts on today's pricing that differs then my findings?
Thanks
Chris Kleban