[1740] in comp.os.os2.announce archive
RESULT: comp.org.team-os2 moderated passes 264:40
daemon@ATHENA.MIT.EDU (Dave Cornejo)
Sun Aug 25 02:39:22 1996
To: os2ann.DISCUSS@bloom-picayune.MIT.EDU
Date: 21 Aug 1996 22:58:54 -0400
From: dave@dogwood.com (Dave Cornejo)
RESULT
moderated group comp.org.team-os2 passes 264:40
There were 264 YES votes and 40 NO votes, for a total of 304 valid
votes. There was 1 abstention and 9 invalid ballots.
For a group to pass, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid
(YES and NO) votes. There must also be at least 100 more YES votes
than NO votes.
A five day discussion period follows this announcement. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the
moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly
thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
comp.org.team-os2 Users promoting the OS/2 operating system. (Moderated)
Voting closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 15 Aug 1996.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions
about this proposal should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: Christian A. Scarborough <ccs95@aber.ac.uk>
Proponent: Jon Duckworth <jond@biddeford.com>
Mentor: Jonathan Grobe <grobe@netins.net>
Votetaker: Dave Cornejo <dave@dogwood.com>
RATIONALE: comp.org.team-os2
Team OS/2 is an international organisation with the aim of promoting
IBM's OS/2 Warp operating system at a grass roots level. There is a
requirement for a news group that allows members to discuss the
matters related to these goals in a relaxed environment. Newsgroups
where such discussion might usually occur are comp.os.os2.advocacy and
alt.org.team-os2. The former group is very high volume, and the
activities of Team OS/2 are of little interest to many subscribers, who
are interested in debating the relative merits of various operating
systems. As a result, the alt.org.team-os2 newsgroup was created.
However, this group has been subject to the problem of poor
propagation, and has also been used for messages more appropriate
to an advocacy group, creating an environment that many Teamers find
intimidating.
CHARTER: comp.org.team-os2
1) comp.org.team-os2 is a moderated newsgroup for the discussion of
information relating to the informal organisiation Team OS/2. This
includes, but is not limited to, OS/2 demos, product announcements,
networking between members, OS/2 user groups, discussion of IBM
marketing of OS/2 and ideas for promoting a wider acceptance of OS/2.
2) The focus of messages posted to the group should be OS/2 and/or Team
OS/2.
3) The following are not appropriate within this group: operating
system advocacy, product advertisements, private "for sale" messages,
technical questions, or personal attacks.
4) The moderator will accept all articles complying with this charter,
Cross posted articles will be posted to all groups listed. The
moderator may, at her discretion, alter the layout of an article to
improve readability, or trim signatures over four lines in length. She
may NOT alter the text of an article deemed to be in compliance with
the charter.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: comp.org.team-os2
Moderator: "Christian A. Scarborough" <ccs95@aber.ac.uk>
Moderator: Gary Hammer <gary@hammer.org>
Moderator: David LaRue <larued@crpl.cedar-rapids.lib.ia.us>
Administrative contact address: comp.org.team-os2-request@teamos2.org
Article submission address: comp.org.team-os2@teamos2.org
END MODERATOR INFO.
DISTRIBUTION:
This CFV has been cross-posted to:
alt.org.team-os2
comp.os.os2.advocacy
comp.os.os2.announce
comp.os.os2.misc
Pointers to the CFV will be posted in these newsgroups:
comp.os.os2.moderated
Pointers to the CFV will be sent to the following lists:
teamos2-l@nic.surfnet.nl
teamos2-l@teamos2.org
comp.org.team-os2 Final Voter list
Voted YES
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
tbm@tci002.uibk.ac.at Martin Michlmayr
rel@lipo.co.at Roland E. Lipovits
h.tschabitscher@magnet.at Heinz Tschabitscher
chris.halliday@mcc.com.au CHRIS HALLIDAY
drizzt@yoyo.cc.monash.edu.au Lachlan O'Dea
9605213z@lux.levels.unisa.edu.au Clusterfer The REE
9605510x@lux.levels.unisa.edu.au Toorak
dpalmer@bunbury.iap.net.au Daren Palmer
ren@mars.nettrek.net.au Ren
dsainty@extro.ucc.su.OZ.AU David Sainty
datarescue@pophost.eunet.be DataRescue sprl
nkerr1@ent.agt.ab.ca Norm Kerr
jcphilli@pop.gov.bc.ca John Phillips
cnichols@langara.bc.ca Sean C. Nichols
jcathie@mindlink.bc.ca
jgoyo@certicom.ca john o goyo
anders@cwconnect.ca Anders Andersen
jefdavis@cycor.ca Jeff & Katie Davis
briel@pfc.forestry.ca Bill G. Riel
sthistle@nlnet.nf.ca Scott L. Thistle
bcurran@freenet.hamilton.on.ca Bill Curran
ac436@freenet.toronto.on.ca Allan Jenoff
bc631@freenet.toronto.on.ca Gabor Liptak
umgreen3@cc.UManitoba.CA Roger Green
cvo132@mackenzie.usask.ca Chike Odigboh
stefan@pink.allcon.com Stefan Behrens
Kirk.Patton@amd.com
Bob_Zielazinski@amrcorp.com Bob Zielazinski
ABDATENTEC@aol.com
EdProchak@aol.com
JoeTom@aol.com
PCDaveS@aol.com
bruce@aracnet.com Bruce Baugh
christij@unix.asb.com Joseph Christie
rick@att.com Rick Suntag
jlink@best.com Jack Link
jond@biddeford.com Jon Duckworth
lfirrantello@BIX.com
larry@bristolpc.bmc.com Larry Bristol
donal@brewich.com Donal
satish@cais.cais.com Satish Rajan
rmeizlik@carroll.com
elliottk@ccnet.com Elliott Kirschling
dnedrow@csi.compuserve.com
71750.2475@CompuServe.COM iwasaki
toad@bbs.cowland.com herb townsend
spelegan@csc.com Stewart Pelegan
mark@datasoft.com Mark Buckaway
idiot@absurd.dialix.com
martin@onyx.dirnet.com Martin Spott
dlv@bwalk.dm.com Dr.Dimitri Vulis KOTM
woods@eaglequest.com Variable
DvdS@eden.com David Vanderschel
hucke@enteract.com Matt Hucke
jetnick@erols.com Jr
taxi@europa.com Taxi
toma@exo.com Jason Hardt
garth@garlic.com John M. Garth
rogert@globaldialog.com Roger Tesch
csr-kts@gol.com Kevin Sullivan
ldeffenb@homeside.com Lynn W. Deffenbaugh (Mr)
clawrenc@xsvr1.cup.hp.com Chris Lawrence (Contra)
jgerken@raleigh.ibm.com John Gerken
john@raleigh.ibm.com
jimmyteo@vnet.ibm.com
timur@VNET.IBM.COM
jcd@ideafarm.com Jon Duringer
nss@idirect.com Noah Sumner
ernfisch@indirect.com Ernie Fisch
rjlapham@infinet.com Jerry Lapham
warnett@inlink.com
paxil@interlog.com Paxil
mike@lionsgate.com Mike Stephen
cah@lonewolf.com Cindy Harris
apilcher@mindspring.com Alan Pilcher
bcoleman@mindspring.com
vev@msen.com Vince Vielhaber
gary@musthave.com
jmw@jmw.mv.com Joseph M. Williams
jmlowman@ix.netcom.com Jim Lowman
scbenes@ix.netcom.com Stephen C. Benes
jadmire@netcom.com Joseph A. Admire
nerwick@netcom.com Randy Nerwick
tjs2@osi.com Tony J. Schlemmer
static@outer-net.com JP Floyd
lbeals@pillarco.com Lawrence F. Beals, Jr.
clp@pobox.com Clifford Pelletier
dantonio@process.com David D'Antonio
bareynol@cca.rockwell.com Brian A. Reynolds
ayhamidou@hkg.ra.rockwell.com Adam Y. Hamidou
EURJOF@eur.sas.com Jochen Friedrich
camp1@seanet.com
deb@karma.roc.servtech.com
heltne@shellus.com
sanjay@sandbox.snetnsa.com Sanjay Aiyagari
dluxford@symantec.com David Luxford
arielle@taronga.com Stephanie da Silva
jiml@teleport.com Jim Little
pccare@teleport.com Patrick West
deb@tink.com
jalcorn@trnet.com Justin B. Alcorn
bern.w@TST-medhat.com Bernard Williams
Kurt.Pinniger@turner.com
vat52132@vat52132.vat-vai.valmet.com
yokki.mika@osi.varian.com Joachim Mika
david@visix.com David Charlap
Nicole.Greiber@FernUni-Hagen.de Nicole Greiber
bossman@bms.franken.de Robert Spangler
dittmer@gkss.de Juergen Dittmer
peter@heirich.in-berlin.de Peter Heirich
DIRK@TRASHCAN.mcnet.de Dirk Hoehne
richard.sturm@muenster.netsurf.de Richard Sturm
mcoane@rhein-neckar.netsurf.de Mike Coane
krischik@salzgitter.netsurf.de Martin Krischik
list-votes@dream.hb.north.de Martin Schr"oder
Christian_Langanke@notes.oerag.de Christian Langanke
jrb@burn.rhein-ruhr.de Johannes Roland Bruns
kowalski@acme2.ruhr.de Thorsten Kowalski
m_pegam@keltic.ruhr.de Manfred Pegam
rabe@RWTH-Aachen.DE Ralf G. R. Bergs
kukuk@berlin.snafu.de Guenter Kukkukk
Ralf.Eichler@koe2.x400scn.sni.de Ralf Eichler
COCO@dream.si.sub.de Marco Steinbach
FP@TeamOS2.DE Florian Piekert
portele@rbg.informatik.th-darmstadt.de Andreas Portele
greve@rs1.thch.uni-bonn.de Thomas Greve
stolt@physnet.uni-hamburg.de Matthias Stolt
kronz@dfki.uni-kl.de Juergen Kronz
jabo@joker.pmnet.uni-oldenburg.de Heiko Jabusch
stiffel@dfki.uni-sb.de Patric \"never up b4 12\" Stiffel
Uwe.Schlenther@studbox.uni-stuttgart.de Uwe Schlenther
guldager@daimi.aau.dk Hans Guldager Knudsen
sparre@fys.ku.dk Jacob Sparre Andersen
Prof.Stanley@asu.edu
zarembka@ACSU.Buffalo.EDU Paul Zarembka
morpheus+@CMU.EDU Gautam Srikanth
cls48@columbia.edu Christopher Lodge Stamper
d.greenberger@cornell.edu David J. Greenberger
eds2@cornell.edu Eric Scharff
kend@csufresno.edu Ken Diliberto
AFECU@CUNYVM.CUNY.EDU Aron Eisenpress
lxh16@po.cwru.edu Lila Hanft
gt9129c@prism.gatech.edu Jason Bennett
ian@hawaii.edu Ian Gibbons
zbachore@kumc.edu Zewudie Bachore
LSEAMANS@MU3.MILLERSV.EDU Lynne Seamans
ccchas@showme.missouri.edu
tojst1+@pitt.edu Tore Joergensen
irv@cs.rutgers.edu Irving N. Rabinowitz
biegel@tigris.stanford.edu Bryan Biegel
gaetano@dmi.stevens-tech.edu
rsantore@mailbox.syr.edu Robert C. Santore
r2bkm@VM1.CC.UAKRON.EDU Belete Muturo
acrosby@comp.uark.edu Albert Crosby
mtpins@isca.uiowa.edu Michael T Pins
gwb@umd5.umd.edu George Baltz
jderrico@j.imap.itd.umich.edu John Anthony D'Errico
sryder2@nova.umuc.edu Scot D. Ryder
shether@med.unc.edu Seth Hetherington
davisf@unvax.union.edu
sad@utkux1.utk.edu Deutscher
mlevis@runner.jpl.utsa.edu Mike Levis - OS/2 Warp 3
trowe@aae.wisc.edu Tom Rowe
derek.diget@wmich.edu Derek L. Diget
stealth@WPI.EDU Robert J. Caputo
chang@wsu.edu Ching-Mo Chang
archer@hsc.fr Vincent Archer
albert@ulysse.ign.fr Albert Bergonzo
ortega@ccr.jussieu.fr Thomas ORTEGA
burgess@lbur.loc.gov
gohast@iol.ie Graham Hastings
baruch@actcom.co.il Baruch Even
poleur@crpcu.lu Michel Poleur
falbof@rl.af.mil F. Robert Falbo
thomasc@rl.af.mil Carl Thomas
SMarvin@TISCOM.USCG.MIL
lzardman@aa.net
dennis.p.roth@worldnet.att.net Dennis Roth
normanmo@clark.net Norm
jugerie@clic.net Jean-Louis Renaud
atavas@connectmmic.net Ahmad Tavassoli
dave@crosslink.net Dave Holt
brihall@digital.net Brian Hall
rjacox@exis.net Richard Jacox
ramey@ipof.fla.net Dwayne Ramey
roussin@genesis8.frmug.fr.net EMMANUEL ROUSSIN
New.Power.Generation@ms1.hinet.net Thomas Ho
lenard@hsonline.net Lenard Charters
avi@ibm.net Avi Schwartz
awesley@ibm.net
baloo@ibm.net Odd Ravn
bej@ibm.net Brian Jongekryg
crayger@ibm.net Craig Miller
cwalshe@ibm.net
DenverD@IBM.Net
doengi@ibm.net Alex Doengi
elwoo@ibm.net Elton Woo
hardym@ibm.net Marc Hardy
joergr@ibm.net Joerg Ruhe
mikyg@ibm.net M. Goddard
natrell@ibm.net
parker0@ibm.net
reinoso@ibm.net Delfi Reinoso
rrs0059@ibm.net Frank McKenney
rspring@ibm.net Rob Springall
stipebr@ibm.net Bert Stipelcovich
torben3@ibm.net
jcdick@igateway.net
bmccombs@iglobal.net
rs@ham.island.net
dhartung@mcs.net Dan Hartung
schmidtj@mcs.net James Schmidt
vinger@mhtc.net Rick Vinger
ondracek@MTS.Net
rveraa@netside.net Rich Veraa
birchall@email.njin.net Dan "Shag" Birchall
alexl@oklahoma.net Alex Lindsay
slubbs@prolog.net Stephen Lubbs
jkusters@shilts.punk.net
obie@shadow.net Obie
bob@sky.net Bob Batson
afcasta@texas.net Al Castanoli
rserafin@texas.net Bob Serafin
acme@use.usit.net Erich Schulman (KTN4CA) Team OS/2
townleyc@townleyc.win-uk.net Chris Townley
editor@zipnet.net S.A
R.M.van.Schouwen@caiw.nl Reinout van Schouwen
R.van.Poelgeest@caiw.nl Robert van Poelgeest
viper@cyber.iaf.nl Robin Vley
onno.tesink@lgthouse.iaf.nl Onno Tesink
HenkJ@burundi.idn.nl Henk Jonkman
huug@telebyte.nl huug
galactus@stack.urc.tue.nl Arnoud "Galactus" Engelfriet
hom@via.nl Pieter van den Hombergh
arnold@mallos.xs4all.nl Arnold Schekkerman
mfvl@xs4all.nl Michiel van Loon
erikmo@sn.no Erik Mogensen
gs@vestkunst.no gaute singstad
steven.evans@snoopys.gen.nz Steven Evans
tkriley@acm.org Thomas K. Riley
hg@penny.n2wx.ampr.org Howard Goldstein
iwasaki@cb.cshl.org Ryutaro Iwasaki
mcraig@fortnet.org Wiz
kwstreet@io.org Kevin Street
trebla@io.org Albert Y.C. Lai
sthoenna@peak.org A.R. & F.L. Scott-Thoennes
shorter.rankin@sacpcug.org Shorter Rankin
jjaworski@wpcusrgrp.org Jim Jaworski
kstrieby@wpcusrgrp.org Karl Strieby
smahomad@mail.telepac.pt
tignat@gemma.geo.uaic.ro Tudor Ignat
mikael.nordlin@abc.se Nordlin, Mikael
janswa@algonet.se
etolah@eto.ericsson.se Lars Hofstad
martin@nmgab.se
x_oa@sectra.se Ola Angelsmark
bengt.sjoberg@mbox201.swipnet.se Bengt Sjvberg
englf@singnet.com.sg Felix Eng
hsbay@singnet.com.sg Bay Hock Seng
ccs95@aber.ac.uk Christian Scarborough
rwself@globalnet.co.uk R.W. Self
ajay@truffula.sj.ca.us Ajay Tallam
mfoster@cp.duluth.mn.us mark foster
Voted NO
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ed.Wilts@gems1.gov.bc.ca Ed Wilts
neeri@iis.ee.ethz.ch Matthias Neeracher
satchell@accutek.com Stephen Satchell
devuns@alsys.com Olivier Devuns @pulsar
dlhanson@amoco.com David L. Hanson
dfulton169@aol.com DFulton169
stainles@bga.com Dwight Brown
zed@cjnetworks.com Ned Fleming
Karl@crl.com Karl Golub
booda@datasync.com Martin H. Booda
mikel@dosbears.com Mike Lipsie
john@kodak.com John Hall x66472
landisj@nad.com Joe Landis
LucienVE@ix.netcom.com Lucien Van Elsen
sylvain@ix.netcom.com Nicholas Sylvain
qut@netcom.com Dave Harman
kim@shell.portal.com Kim DeVaughn
pan@syix.com Pan
bonine@xochi.tezcat.com Steve Bonine
eggert@twinsun.com Paul Eggert
naddy@mips.pfalz.de Christian Weisgerber
hwm@hamster.sauerland.de Hartmut W. Malzahn
M.Lobenhofer@t-online.de Lobenhofer Magnus/RB
ml3e+@andrew.cmu.edu Michael Loomis
dsr@lns598.lns.cornell.edu Daniel S. Riley
patl@lcs.mit.edu Patrick J. LoPresti
vivek@cs.rice.edu Vivek Sadananda Pai
rra@cs.stanford.edu Russ Allbery
rick@bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller
afabbro@umich.edu Andrew Philip Fabbro
geisler@mcs.anl.gov Jonathan Geisler
msoysal@mistik.express.net Mustafa Soysal MS57
elde@hurricane.net Derek Lyons
itimms@ibm.net Ian Timms
larmondin@ica.net Fred Larmondin
john@handel.jlc.net John Leslie
shrao@nyx.net Shrisha Rao
fnord@odyssee.net Thomas Moll
tonys@wt.net Tony Storz
tlawson@amug.org Todd C. Lawson
Abstained
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PMVwFr@ibm.net Raphael Vanney
Invalid ballots
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
jrapp%warwick.net@host
! Invalid address
! No address
Rakateer@cris.com
! No vote statement in message
rdmyers@e2.empirenet.com Rodney D. Myers
! No vote statement in message
enk@pip.dknet.dk Henrik Enk
! No vote statement in message
jbrush@aros.net John Brush
! No vote statement in message
bwsmith@fullnet.net
! No vote statement in message
jniffen@mpr.org
! No vote statement in message
kaufman@loxinfo.co.th Peter Kaufman
! No vote statement in message
